As part of the Build America 250 Act, the federal government has proposed a federal tax on all electric vehicles of $130 per year, increasing to $150 per year after 2 years. This is proposed "because EVs don't pay fuel taxes and are so much heavier than ICE vehicles".
As I have written elsewhere, I am not opposed to paying my fair share to support the infrastructure I use, as long as it's my fair share and not mine and someone else's as well.
So let's run the numbers.
I have a 2017 Chevy Bolt, with a curb weight of 3582 pounds. Round it up to 3600 to make the math easier.
According to the EPA, the average curb weight for light duty vehicles is 4372 pounds. The average fuel economy for conventional gasoline vehicles is 22.4 mpg, with SUVs at around 18.6 mpg and compact cars at 26.2 mpg.
So, my Bolt is already 800 pounds lighter than the average.
I have a 44 mile daily commute, plus about that much on weekends, so figure 13,728 miles per year.
The average vehicle would burn about 613 gallons of fuel during the year, assuming the same commute I have.
At $0.184/gal federal gasoline tax, that would be about $113 per year in fuel taxes. So remind me again why I'm being asked to pay 30% more for a vehicle that weighs 20% less?
As I have written elsewhere, the real problem isn't that EVs are paying too little, but that gasoline vehicles aren't paying enough.
The federal gasoline tax was set at $0.184/gallon in 1993. According to the inflation calculator published by the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, in order to have the same buying power today, the federal gasoline tax would have to be $0.42/gallon just to keep up with inflation. Unfortunately, any proposal to nearly triple the federal gasoline tax would be political suicide, because car drivers really like their very heavily subsidized roads, even as they're complaining that EV drivers aren't paying our fair share.
No comments:
Post a Comment